← All reports

SIE.DE · GER · Industrials · Specialty Industrial Machinery

Siemens Aktiengesellschaft

Report 2026-11-21 · figures in EUR · Benjamin Graham, The Intelligent Investor

Data warnings

Verdict · mechanical valuation (the more conservative of two)
OVERVALUED
Price254.65 EUR
Buy below (low × 0.67)68.84 EUR
Intrinsic value mid148.31 EUR
Mid-based buy price (reference)99.37 EUR

Intrinsic value range 102.75 – 174.71 EUR · margin of safety 33%. BUY ≤ buy-below · WATCH ≤ mid-based buy price · HOLD/FAIR ≤ mid value · OVERVALUED above mid.

Defensive: 2 of 7 pass · Enterprising: 2 of 6 pass

What to look at

  1. How far from a Graham buy?

    The price would have to fall 73% to reach the buy-below price (68.84 EUR), and 42% to reach Graham's mid value (148.31 EUR).

    A fall of that size happens in a market sell-off: worth keeping on a watchlist.

  2. What growth does the price assume?

    Today's price only makes sense if earnings grow 6.7% a year for 10 years (and you want a 9% yearly return).

    That is slower than its past growth (24.5%/yr): the market expects a slowdown, which leaves some room if growth holds up.

    Reverse DCF details ↓
  3. Is it a great business? (quality lens, not Graham)

    5 of 5 quality checks pass.

    Its free-cash-flow value is 359.27 EUR; the price is 29% below that.

    The price matches that value if free cash flow would grow 4.4% a year (past: 9.0%/yr).

    Quality details ↓
  4. How each approach reads this

    Graham investor: not a buy at this price. Look for cheaper companies (see the starter list in the README).

    Quality investor: a strong business; only interesting if you believe free cash flow can grow 4.4%/yr or better for 10 years.

Data completeness

SeriesYearsSpan
Revenue4 of 10 2023–2026
Net income4 of 10 2023–2026
EPS (diluted)4 of 10 2022–2025
Dividends per share5 of 10 2022–2026
Book value per share4 of 10 2023–2026
Current assets4 of 10 2023–2026
Current liabilities4 of 10 2023–2026
Long-term debt5 of 10 2022–2026
Intangibles4 of 10 2023–2026
Operating cash flow4 of 10 2023–2026
Capital expenditure4 of 10 2023–2026
Annual figures
20222023202420252026
Revenue—74.88B75.93B78.91B83.37B
Net income—7.95B8.30B9.62B8.49B
EPS (diluted)4.599.9110.3812.11—
Dividend / share4.004.254.705.205.35
Book value / share—60.4965.3279.7790.52
Current assets—60.64B61.35B64.71B68.86B
Current liabilities—44.91B43.91B47.26B47.56B
Long-term debt41.68B36.88B38.98B42.34B39.41B
Total equity—47.78B51.26B62.24B69.24B
Shares809.68M789.92M784.87M780.26M764.94M
Intangibles—42.87B40.98B52.87B53.35B
Operating cash flow—12.24B11.66B13.26B14.67B
Capital expenditure—2.15B2.09B2.44B2.57B
Free cash flow—10.09B9.58B10.81B12.10B

Defensive investor criteria (ch. 14)

Enterprising investor criteria (ch. 15)

Valuation (mechanical)

Graham number148.31 EUR
√(22.5 × 3-yr avg EPS × BVPS)
3-yr avg EPS
10.80
EPS years
2023–2025
Book value / share
90.52
Graham revised formula174.71 EUR
EPS × (8.5 + 2g) × 4.4 / Y
3-yr avg EPS
10.80
g (%)
7.00
Y = AAA yield (%)
6.12
Earnings power value102.75 EUR
normalised EPS / discount rate
Normalised EPS
9.25
EPS years
2022–2025
Discount rate (%)
9.00
RangeLowMidHigh
Intrinsic value102.75148.31174.71
× (1 − 0.33)68.8499.37

Reverse DCF: what growth does the price assume?

A reverse DCF turns the question around: instead of estimating value from assumed growth, it takes today's price and solves for the yearly earnings growth that would justify it, if you want a 9% yearly return.

Reverse DCF (implied growth)6.7% / yr
g such that price = PV of 10 yrs of EPS growing at g + 15× terminal, at 9%
Price
254.65
Latest EPS
12.11
Discount rate (%)
9.00
Terminal multiple
15.00

The market price assumes EPS grows 6.7% a year for 10 years, no more than the 7.0% used above. Not part of the value range.

Sensitivity

Mid value (buy-below underneath) for growth g ±2 pp and rates ±1 pp. The rate shift moves both the EPV discount rate and the AAA yield Y.

g \ r8%9%10%
5.0%148.3177.45143.6568.84123.4761.96
7.0%148.3177.45148.3168.84148.3161.96
9.0%148.3177.45148.3168.84148.3161.96

AI assumptions vs mechanical

MechanicalAI-adjusted
Growth g7.0%4.0%
EPS adjustmentsnone0
Cyclical treatmentnoyes
Graham number148.31148.31
Graham revised formula174.71109.70
Earnings power value102.75102.75
Range low – high102.75 – 174.71102.75 – 148.31
Buy below68.8468.84
VerdictOVERVALUEDOVERVALUED

The headline uses the lower buy-below price (mechanical).

Growth rate: 4.0%

Revenue rose from 74.88B (2023) to 83.37B (2026), and diluted EPS rose from 9.91 (2023) to 12.11 (2025). The mechanical 24.5%/yr figure is distorted by the low 2022 EPS of 4.59. Net income fell from 9.62B (2025) to 8.49B (2026), so I assume modest, conservative growth.

Cyclical: yes

Siemens is an industrial machinery and automation business, and its EPS moved from 4.59 (2022) to 9.91 (2023) and 12.11 (2025). Net income then dropped from 9.62B (2025) to 8.49B (2026), which shows earnings swinging with the cycle and with portfolio effects.

AI-adjusted valuation details
Graham number148.31 EUR
√(22.5 × 3-yr avg EPS × BVPS)
3-yr avg EPS
10.80
EPS years
2023–2025
Book value / share
90.52
Graham revised formula109.70 EUR
EPS × (8.5 + 2g) × 4.4 / Y
normalised EPS (cyclical)
9.25
g (%)
4.00
Y = AAA yield (%)
6.12
Earnings power value102.75 EUR
normalised EPS / discount rate
Normalised EPS
9.25
EPS years
2022–2025
Discount rate (%)
9.00

Quality at a fair price (not Graham)

Graham's tests favour cheap, asset-heavy companies, so strong asset-light businesses almost always fail them. This section takes a different view: is it a high-quality business, and what is it worth on its free cash flow? It is not used in the verdict above.

Free-cash-flow value

Fair value359.27 EUR
Buy below (fair × 0.67)240.71 EUR
10 yrs of FCF/share growing at g, then 2.5%/yr forever, discounted at 9%
FCF per share (avg 2024–2026)
13.96
Growth g (10 yrs)
9.0%
Discount rate
9.0%
Terminal growth
2.5%
Price
254.65
Growth implied by price
4.4%

Historical FCF/share growth 9.0%/yr, bounded to 0–10%.

What if growth is…

FCF growth, next 10 yrsValue / sharevs price
0% / yr182.54-28%
5% / yr265.73+4%
10% / yr387.96+52%
15% / yr565.76+122%

Pick the growth you find realistic. If its value is well above the price, the price leaves room for error at that growth.

Free cash flow per share by year
202312.78
202412.20
202513.86
202615.81

Analysis

The business

Siemens Aktiengesellschaft is a large industrial technology group. It sells automation and industrial machinery, along with related software and infrastructure equipment. It earns money from selling equipment and systems, and from the services and software that go with them. In FY2026 revenue was 83.37B EUR and net income was 8.49B EUR, down from 9.62B EUR in 2025.

Durable competitive advantages

Siemens appears to have durable advantages in its scale, its installed base of industrial equipment and its engineering and software expertise. Customers who adopt its automation systems tend to face high switching costs. The financial record is consistent with this: net income was positive in all 5 years of data, and the dividend has been paid for 27 consecutive years. These are inferences from the figures, as the data contains no direct measure of market share or pricing power.

Key risks

The balance sheet is the main weakness under Graham's rules. Long-term debt is 39.41B EUR against net current assets of 21.30B EUR, and the current ratio is 1.45. Intangibles are 53.35B EUR against equity of 69.24B EUR, so tangible backing is thin, at 24.93 EUR per share. Earnings also swing with the cycle and with portfolio changes: EPS was 4.59 in 2022 and 12.11 in 2025, and net income fell in 2026. At 254.65 EUR the price sits above every mechanical valuation estimate, so a disappointment would hurt. The analysis is also limited by only 4 to 5 years of data out of the 10 Graham prefers.

Bull case

Revenue grew from 74.88B EUR in 2023 to 83.37B EUR in 2026, and the dividend rose from 4.25 to 5.35 EUR per share. Operating cash flow reached 14.66B EUR in 2026. Separately from Graham's verdict, the cash-flow quality view passes all five of its checks, including cash conversion of 124% and a debt payback of 3.6 years. The price implies about 4.44% free-cash-flow growth in that view. If Siemens keeps compounding cash flow, the premium to Graham's yardsticks could be sustained.

Bear case

Graham's methods put value well below the market price. The Graham number is 148.31, the revised formula gives 174.71 and earnings power value is 102.75, against a price of 254.65. The mechanical buy-below level is 68.84. Net income dropped in 2026, so recent EPS strength may have been near a peak. The company combines a high P/E of 22.6 with a P/B of 2.81, and heavy debt and intangibles leave little cushion if earnings fall.

Why it passes or fails Graham's tests

Siemens does not pass Graham's defensive test. It passes on size (D1, 83.37B EUR revenue, about 91.46B USD) and on dividend record (D4, 27 consecutive years). Earnings stability (D3, 5 of 5 years positive) and earnings growth (D5, +55% between two-year averages) are partial passes, because only 5 of 10 years of data exist. It fails financial condition (D2): the current ratio is 1.45 against the 2 required, and long-term debt of 39.41B EUR exceeds net current assets of 21.30B EUR. Valuation fails as well. D6 shows a P/E of 22.6 against a limit of 15 times average EPS, and D7 shows P/B of 2.81 with P/E × P/B of 63.7 against the 22.5 limit. Both are partial results that lean to fail because of limited data.

On the enterprising test, Siemens passes earnings stability (E3) and current dividend (E4, 5.35 EUR). It fails the current ratio (E1, 1.45 against 1.5), debt versus net current assets (E2) and price versus net tangible assets (E6, 254.65 against 24.93 for 1.2 × NTA per share). E5 could not be assessed because latest EPS is missing. Overall the verdict is OVERVALUED. The cash-flow quality checks are a separate lens and are not part of Graham's verdict.

Written by an AI model from the figures above. Every number in this text was checked against the computed data.

What the market thinks

Consensus ratingbuy (2.0 on 1–5, 1 = strong buy)
Mean price target310.65 EUR
Analysts23

Shown for context only. Analyst opinions are not used in the valuation or the verdict.

Sources and timestamps

Financial statements

Revenue
yfinancerevenue 2023–2026
Net income
yfinancenet_income 2023–2026
EPS (diluted)
yfinanceeps_diluted 2022–2025
Dividend / share
yfinancecalendar-year dividends 2022–2026
Total equity
yfinancetotal_equity 2023–2026
Current assets
yfinancecurrent_assets 2023–2026
Current liabilities
yfinancecurrent_liabilities 2023–2026
Long-term debt
yfinancelong_term_debt 2022–2026
Operating cash flow
yfinanceoperating_cash_flow 2023–2026
Capital expenditure
yfinancecapex 2023–2026
Shares
yfinanceshares_instant 2023–2026shares_weighted 2022
Intangibles
yfinancegoodwill_and_intangibles 2023–2026
Book value / share
derivedtotal_equity / shares_outstanding

Market data and this run

Price
254.65 EUR · yfinance2026-11-21 15:31 UTC
AAA yield (Y)
6.12%FRED AAA (Moody's Seasoned Aaa Corporate Bond Yield), 2026-10-01
Dividend history
yfinance dividend history (calendar-year totals, split-adjusted)coverage from 1996
Analyst consensus
yfinance (analyst consensus)
Generated
2026-11-21 15:31 UTC
AI usage
anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.52 calls · 9,789 in / 2,677 out tokens · $0.0463

Not financial advice. This report is generated automatically from public data for personal research. Data can be incomplete or wrong; figures are not audited. It gives signals only and never trades. Check the filings before making any decision.